What is Blue Nile's return window?

Blue Nile allows returns within 30 days from the shipment date. of purchase. Items must be in their original, unworn condition. All original packaging and documentation, including any laboratory grading reports, must be included. A Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) number is required for all returns.

Do I need a receipt to return items at Blue Nile?

Receipt requirement: digital ok. Refunds are issued to the original form of payment..

← All return policies

Blue Nile Return Policy

Last verified: 2026-03-20

Official Blue Nile PolicyVerified

www.bluenile.com/policies/returns

2026-03-20

Summary

Blue Nile offers a 30 days from the shipment date. return window on most items. Items must be in their original, unworn condition.. Receipt is required. Refunds are issued via refunds are issued to the original form of payment.. Notable exceptions include personalized jewelry, custom orders, and engraved items are not eligible for return or exchange., items that have been re-sized after the initial purchase cannot be returned., purchases from the diamond upgrade program, clearance, and items marked as "final sale" are not returnable., and more.

Return Window

30 days from the shipment date.

Receipt

digital ok

Video Guides

Search on YouTube

Return Conditions

Items must be in their original, unworn condition.
All original packaging and documentation, including any laboratory grading reports, must be included.
A Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) number is required for all returns.

Refund Methods

Refunds are issued to the original form of payment.

Exceptions & Restrictions

Personalized jewelry, custom orders, and engraved items are not eligible for return or exchange.
Items that have been re-sized after the initial purchase cannot be returned.
Purchases from the Diamond Upgrade program, Clearance, and items marked as "Final Sale" are not returnable.
Engraved rings will be charged a $25 repolishing fee.

Online / Mail Returns

To initiate a return, you can chat with customer service, log into your online account, or create an account using the same email as your order.
A free, fully insured return shipping label will be emailed to you.
There is a limit of two complimentary returns per customer, per year.

Gift Returns

Gifts can be exchanged for merchandise credit within 30 days of purchase.
The original purchaser will not be notified of the return.

Damaged or Defective Items

If an item arrives damaged, refuse the shipment or contact Blue Nile immediately at 1-800-242-2728.
Retain all original packing materials.
Claims for damaged or missing items must be reported within five days of receipt.

Exchange Policy

For the fastest service, Blue Nile recommends returning the original item for a refund and placing a new order for the different product.
Exchanges must be done in-store.

Additional Notes

If a diamond grading report is not returned, a $150 replacement fee will be charged.
Refunds for purchases made by bank wire will be processed within seven to 10 business days.
Refunds for PayPal purchases will be credited back to your PayPal account within two weeks.

What Redditors Are Saying

Search on Reddit

r/Diamonds·2y ago

Canadian returns/refunds to the US (James Allen, blue Nile etc)

When buying from Canada we pay tax at the door. Now there are free returns. But who refunds the tax paid at the door? And is it a simple process or a nightmare? James Allen states they do not refund tax as they do not collect it

3 comments

r/EngagementRings·2y ago

Canadian returns/ refunds to the US (blue Nile, James Allen)

When buying from Canada we pay tax at the door. Now there are free returns. But who refunds the tax paid at the door? And is it a simple process or a nightmare?

3 comments