How do I get a refund from Papa John's?

Steps: Identify if your pizza meets the conditions of unsatisfactory quality according to Papa John's Quality Guarantee. Have your receipt or order information available. Call the specific Papa John's restaurant where your pizza was ordered and made. Make your claim on the same day as the original order, within thirty (30) minutes of the delivery or pick-up time. For carry-out orders, return the original pizza order to the same restaurant. For delivery orders, a replacement pizza will be delivered to the same address as the original order.

What refund methods does Papa John's offer?

Replacement pizza of equal or lesser value for unsatisfactory pizzas.. Removal of preauthorization hold for cancelled online orders..

← All refund guides

Papa John's Refund Policy

Last verified: 2026-03-19

Official Papa John's PolicyVerified

www.papajohns.com/company/quality-guarantee.html

2026-03-19

Summary

Papa John's offers refunds within Same day as the original order, within 30 minutes of delivery or pick-up for Quality Guarantee claims.. Processing time: For cancelled online orders, preauthorization holds can take 1-5 business days for debit cards and 3-30 business days for other financial institutions to be removed.. Refund methods include replacement pizza of equal or lesser value for unsatisfactory pizzas. and removal of preauthorization hold for cancelled online orders.. Applies only to pizzas ordered and purchased directly from Papa John's that are not of satisfactory quality (e.g., temperature (cold), undercooked/overcooked pizza, skimpy toppings, wrong pizza/toppings, damaged pizza)..

Refund Window

Same day as the original order, within 30 minutes of delivery or pick-up for Quality Guarantee claims.

Processing Time

For cancelled online orders, preauthorization holds can take 1-5 business days for debit cards and 3-30 business days for other financial institutions to be removed.

Refund Method

Replacement pizza of equal or lesser value for unsatisfactory pizzas.

How to Get a Refund — Step by Step

1Identify if your pizza meets the conditions of unsatisfactory quality according to Papa John's Quality Guarantee.
2Have your receipt or order information available.
3Call the specific Papa John's restaurant where your pizza was ordered and made.
4Make your claim on the same day as the original order, within thirty (30) minutes of the delivery or pick-up time.
5For carry-out orders, return the original pizza order to the same restaurant.
6For delivery orders, a replacement pizza will be delivered to the same address as the original order.

When You Can Get a Refund

Applies only to pizzas ordered and purchased directly from Papa John's that are not of satisfactory quality (e.g., temperature (cold), undercooked/overcooked pizza, skimpy toppings, wrong pizza/toppings, damaged pizza).
Excludes issues regarding delivery time.
Does not apply to sides, drinks, or desserts.
No more than two (2) slices of the original pizza may have been eaten.
Valid proof of purchase must be shown upon request.
Papa Pass Cards are non-refundable once relinquished to the fundraiser representative.
PapaPriority fees are non-refundable.
Papa John's Gift Cards cannot be returned or refunded.

All Refund Methods

Replacement pizza of equal or lesser value for unsatisfactory pizzas.
Removal of preauthorization hold for cancelled online orders.

Partial Refunds

Cash refunds are not available for unsatisfactory pizzas; only a replacement pizza is offered under the Quality Guarantee.

Dispute Process

For fraud related to Papa Pass Cards, contact the police and file a report. Papa John's can be contacted to report the incident but cannot offer refunds or take action for fraudulent activity.
For general customer service concerns, contact Papa John's customer service via phone at (877) 547-7272, online contact form, or live chat.

Additional Notes

Papa John's offers a 'Quality Guarantee' for pizzas not meeting quality standards, providing a free replacement pizza.
The Quality Guarantee does not offer a cash alternative or refund.
Papa Pass Cards and Papa John's Gift Cards are non-refundable.
PapaPriority fees are non-refundable.

What Redditors Are Saying

Search on Reddit

3770

r/tipping·1y ago

Papa John’s didn’t want to refund a tip for delivery that I picked up myself

I ordered a pizza from Papa John’s from their app for delivery to our home and added a $5 driver tip. We normally get our deliveries from them within 30 minutes. After waiting an hour, I called the store to find out when the pizza was being delivered. They said they only had one delivery guy, so it

277 comments