← All comparisons

Kohl's vs JCPenney Return Policy

Side-by-side comparison of return policies, conditions, and refund methods.·Last updated: 2026-03-19

Quick Summary

Kohl's offers a Most items: 90 days. Kohl's Card holders: 120 days. Premium electronics/watches: 30 days. Sephora items purchased Nov 1-Dec 31: extended until Jan 31 of following year. Registry items: 365 days. return window, while JCPenney offers Most items: 60 days. Fitness trackers and smartwatches: 10 days. Jewelry boxes and armoires: 30 days of delivery. Fine jewelry and watches: 60 days.. Kohl's can look up purchases without a receipt, and JCPenney requires a receipt. Kohl's offers a holiday return extension. JCPenney offers a holiday return extension. See the full breakdown below.

Kohl's Holiday Extension

Special extended return window until January 31st for premium electronics, watches, and Sephora items bought after November 1st.

JCPenney Holiday Extension

Purchases made on or after Oct. 1 are eligible for return or exchange through Jan. 31 of the following year.

Return Conditions

Kohl's

  • Merchandise must be in new, unused, unwashed condition and in its original packaging.
  • Beauty items just need to be new or gently used.
  • Original tags should be attached.

JCPenney

  • Most returns accepted at any JCPenney store.
  • Fine jewelry and watches must be free of any signs of wear, unworn, unaltered, and in original condition with packaging and accompanying accessories.
  • Certified Jewelry should be returned with the certificate.

Exceptions & Restrictions

Kohl's

  • Beverages are non-returnable.
  • Opened breast pumps and accessories are non-returnable.
  • Sephora 'final sale' items are non-returnable.
  • Used/damaged beauty products (unless gently used) are non-returnable.
  • Premium electronics/watches after 30 days are non-returnable.
  • Any item that fails third-party verification is non-returnable.
  • Final sale or special promotion items may have restrictions.

JCPenney

  • Protective Face Masks are final sale.
  • Body Jewelry/Ear Piercing Kits are final sale.
  • Special Orders/Personalized Gifts cannot be returned after delivery and acceptance.
  • Furniture returns incur a 15% restocking fee and $85 pick-up fee; defects must be reported within 48 hours.
  • Made-to-Measure Blinds, Shades, Shutters, and Draperies are custom orders and can only be cancelled within 24 hours for a refund, or returned if damaged/defective.
  • Digital Images and CDs (Portrait) cannot be returned or exchanged.
  • Merchandise returns shipped directly from a vendor are not accepted in store.

Refund Methods

Kohl's

  • Original form of payment (with receipt/proof of purchase).
  • Store credit (for non-receipted returns).
  • Refunds processed proportionally if gift card or Nordstrom Note was used with a credit card.

JCPenney

  • Original form of payment (with receipt).
  • JCPenney Gift Card.
  • JCPenney Merchandise Return Voucher (for returns without receipt or after 60 days if approved).

Online / Mail Returns

Kohl's

  • Can be returned by mail. Shipping costs are not refunded for mail returns.
  • Can be returned in-store. This option is free and usually processes faster.

JCPenney

  • By mail: A flat $8 UPS return fee is deducted from your refund when using the prepaid label. Customers are responsible for return postage if not using prepaid label.
  • In-store: Any item bought online may be returned to a JCPenney store for free.

In-Store Returns

Kohl's

  • Items purchased in-store can be returned to any Kohl's location.
  • Bring items to the Customer Service counter along with your order number or receipt.

JCPenney

  • Most returns are accepted at any JCPenney store within 60 days of purchase.
  • Bring item(s) and your receipt.

Gift Returns

Kohl's

Not available

JCPenney

  • With a gift receipt, refunds will be to original payment or a JCPenney Gift Card.

Membership Benefits

Kohl's

  • Kohl's Card holders receive a 120-day return window on most items.

JCPenney

Not available

Damaged or Defective Items

Kohl's

Not available

JCPenney

  • Defects or damages must be reported within 48 hours of delivery for furniture and jewelry boxes/armoires.

Price Adjustments

Kohl's

Not available

JCPenney

  • JCPenney will match a lower advertised price from a competitor within 14 days of purchase.

Exchange Policy

Kohl's

Not available

JCPenney

  • Most merchandise purchased in the last 60 days can be exchanged at any JCPenney location.
  • Exchange rules are the same as those for returning products.

Additional Notes

Kohl's

  • Shipping costs paid on Kohls.com orders are not refunded.
  • Kohl's can look up purchases for non-receipted returns.
  • Kohl's reserves the right to limit or refuse returns and may require ID verification for return fraud monitoring.

JCPenney

  • Valid photo identification is required for all non-receipted returns or exchanges; information from ID will be retained.
  • JCPenney reserves the right to limit returns or exchanges with or without a valid receipt.
  • For returns in CT and MA, sales tax refund is given only if returned within 60 days.