← All comparisons

Jared vs Kay Jewelers (Signet) Return Policy

Side-by-side comparison of return policys, conditions, and refund methods.·Last updated: 2026-03-20

Quick Summary

Jared offers a 30 days return window, while Kay Jewelers (Signet) offers Returns are allowed within 30 days from the purchase (shipment) date for jewelry and watches. Exchanges for jewelry are allowed within 60 days from the purchase (shipment) date, and watches within 30 days.. Jared requires a receipt, and Kay Jewelers (Signet) requires a receipt. See the full breakdown below.

Return Conditions

Jared

  • Items must be in their original condition.
  • All original packaging, instructions, and paperwork must be included.
  • Watches must be returned with all links.
  • The ReKlaim tag must still be affixed where applicable.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Items must be in their original condition.
  • All original packaging, instructions, and paperwork must be included.
  • Watches must be unworn, unaltered, returned with all links, and accompanied by original packaging, warranty, and instructions.
  • Prior to returning a smartwatch, all data stored on the product must be removed, un-synced, and deleted.
  • Jewelry must be in good condition.

Exceptions & Restrictions

Jared

  • Special ordered watches
  • Custom designs
  • Gift cards (except where required by law)
  • Jewelry that has been engraved or altered/modified beyond sizing or stone setting
  • Protection plan replacement merchandise
  • Merchandise purchased using Progressive Leasing cannot be exchanged.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Special ordered watches cannot be returned or exchanged.
  • Custom designs cannot be returned or exchanged.
  • Ear piercing earrings cannot be returned or exchanged.
  • Gift cards cannot be returned (except where required by law).
  • Jewelry that has been engraved or altered/modified beyond sizing cannot be returned or exchanged.
  • Protection plan replacement merchandise cannot be returned or exchanged.
  • Merchandise purchased using Progressive Leasing cannot be exchanged.
  • Original shipping and handling or other additional costs will not be refunded, unless the item received was damaged, defective, or incorrect.

Refund Methods

Jared

  • Refunds are credited to the same tender as the original purchase.
  • For check purchases or cash refunds over $500, a refund check will be mailed within 21 days.
  • Refunds for items purchased with a gift card will be given as a new gift card.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Credit and Debit Cards: The same account will be credited.
  • Check: A refund check will be issued from the corporate office and mailed within 21 days.
  • Cash: When funds are unavailable or the cash refund amount is greater than $500, a refund check will be issued from the corporate office and mailed within 21 days. When funds are available, cash refunds will be given for amounts under $500.
  • Gift Card: Refunds will be given in the form of a new gift card.
  • Trade-Ins: You will receive either your original trade-in or similar merchandise.

Online / Mail Returns

Jared

  • Returns for online orders can be made for up to 30 days after the date shipped.
  • You must include the packing slip and all original documents with your return.
  • Ship the package pre-paid and insured for the full purchase price.
  • Exchanges must be done in one of their stores.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Returns can be handled at Kay.com.
  • Ship your return to the address provided on your packing slip (SJIX 375 Ghent Rd. Akron, OH 44333).
  • All shipped returns MUST include the Packing Slip and all original documents received with your order.
  • Return reason column next to each item on your packing slip should be completed.
  • Return labels are not pre-paid; customers need to purchase the shipping label from a carrier (UPS, USPS, or Fed Ex).
  • For your protection, it is recommended to use a shipping method that provides insurance and tracking services.
  • If the original packing slip is not available for a mail return, provide your name, address, phone number, email address, and order number.
  • All returns will be inspected by the Quality Assurance team before a refund is issued.

In-Store Returns

Jared

  • You can return or exchange items at any Jared store for up to 30 days after purchase.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Returns can be made to any Kay Jewelers location or any Sterling Family of Jewelers location.
  • Online purchases can be returned to any KAY or KAY Outlet store.
  • For in-store returns of online purchases, the original packing slip, a copy of your ship confirmation email, or an online purchase receipt displayed during checkout is required.
  • Purchases made at a KAY or KAY Outlet store MUST be returned to a KAY or KAY Outlet store; they may NOT be returned by mail.

Gift Returns

Jared

  • Merchandise accompanied by a gift receipt may be returned for a gift card or exchanged for merchandise within 30 days of the purchase date.
  • Online gift purchases can be returned by mail if you have the billing ZIP code and order number.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Merchandise accompanied by a gift receipt may be returned for a gift card or exchanged for merchandise within 30 days of the purchase date.
  • Exchanges for gifts can be made in-store for jewelry within 60 days and watches within 30 days of the purchase or shipment date.
  • If a gift recipient does not have a gift receipt, packing slip, or original receipt, they can visit in-store with the purchaser, who can present an ID.
  • Refunds for gifts are credited to the payment form used at the time of purchase (for the purchaser).

Damaged or Defective Items

Jared

Not available

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • If there is damage to an item upon delivery, call the contact center immediately for assistance.
  • Original shipping and handling or other additional costs will be refunded if you received a damaged, defective, or incorrect item.

Exchange Policy

Jared

Not available

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Jewelry can be exchanged within 60 days from the purchase (shipment) date.
  • Watches can be exchanged within 30 days from the purchase (shipment) date.
  • Exchanges must be done at one of Kay Jewelers' stores; online exchanges are not supported.
  • Items must be in their original condition, with all original packaging, instructions, and paperwork. Watches must include all links.

Additional Notes

Jared

  • Sizing fees for sized-to-order rings that are returned will be refunded.
  • For trade-ins, you will receive either your original trade-in or similar merchandise.

Kay Jewelers (Signet)

  • Refunds are credited to the same tender as the original purchase.
  • If a sized-to-order ring is returned, the sizing fee will be refunded once the return is processed.
  • All products must be returned in good condition, in original boxes, and with all paperwork (such as watch instruction booklet or diamond certificate) and accessories to ensure a full credit.