Comparison

Wayfair vs Overstock (Bed Bath & Beyond)

The two stores' return policies, row by row, each from its official page.

WayfairOverstock (Bed Bath & Beyond)
Return windowMost items within 30 days of delivery. Mattresses within 100 days. Large appliances within 48 hours of delivery if uninstalled.30 Days
ReceiptLookup availableDigital receipt accepted
Refund processing timeRefunds to original payment method typically 3-5 business days, up to 2 weeks. Store credit within 1 business day.—
Holiday extensionItems purchased between November 1 and December 31 can be returned until January 31 of the following year.—

Return conditions

Wayfair

  • Items must be in original, undamaged condition.
  • Items must be unassembled if they arrived that way.
  • Items should be in original packaging; if not available, use similar-sized box (no longer than 108 inches).

Overstock (Bed Bath & Beyond)

  • Item must be new, unused and in its original packaging with all original inserts
  • Return must be initiated within 30 days of delivery
  • Returned item must be received by Overstock’s facility within 45 days of delivery

Exceptions & restrictions

Wayfair

  • Clearance or final sale items are not returnable.
  • Open Box deals are typically final sale.
  • Personalized or made-to-order products are not returnable.
  • Gift cards are not returnable.
  • Live plants and swatches are not returnable.
  • Bundled deals bought at a discount are not returnable unless the entire bundle is returned.
  • Items marked 'Non-Returnable' on the product page.
  • Mattress toppers, crib mattresses, air mattresses, and open box mattresses are excluded from the 100-night trial.
  • Hazardous materials have specific return conditions; contact customer service.
  • Large appliances cannot be returned once installed.

Overstock (Bed Bath & Beyond)

  • Final‑sale or “As Is” items
  • Ink cartridges and Club O memberships
  • Gift cards
  • Mattresses, pillows, bulk items once the wrapping is opened
  • Items marked “Final Sale” cannot be returned for a full refund

Refund methods

Wayfair

  • Original payment method (minus return shipping fees).
  • Store credit (may waive return shipping fees).
  • Wayfair gift card.

Overstock (Bed Bath & Beyond)

  • Refund to the original payment method
  • Shipping charges are refunded only for defective items
  • Refund includes taxes and any customs/tariffs at the time of purchase