Which is easier to cancel, Lemonade or Progressive?

Lemonade can be cancelled via App, Website, Email, Phone. Progressive can be cancelled via Phone call.

Do Lemonade or Progressive charge cancellation fees?

Lemonade: There is no fee or penalty for canceling early.. Progressive: None explicitly stated..

Can I get a refund when I cancel Lemonade or Progressive?

Lemonade: You will receive a refund for the remaining period you’ve already paid for. Lemonade will process unused premiums and send them back to the debit/credit card used to open your account. Progressive: Refunds are typically issued for premiums paid in advance upon cancellation. If paying monthly, refund eligibility depends on the cancellation timing.

← All comparisons

Cancel Lemonade vs Progressive

Side-by-side comparison of cancellations, conditions, and cancellation steps.·Last updated: 2026-03-20

Quick Summary

Lemonade can be cancelled via App, Website, Email, Phone, while Progressive supports Phone call. Lemonade refund eligibility: You will receive a refund for the remaining period you’ve already paid for. Progressive refund eligibility: Refunds are typically issued for premiums paid in advance upon cancellation. Lemonade charges a cancellation fee. Progressive charges a cancellation fee. See the full breakdown below.

Lemonade

Methods

App, Website, Email, Phone

Refund Eligibility

You will receive a refund for the remaining period you’ve already paid for

Fee

There is no fee or penalty for canceling early.

Progressive

Methods

Phone call

Refund Eligibility

Refunds are typically issued for premiums paid in advance upon cancellation

Fee

None explicitly stated.

Cancellation Steps

Lemonade

Log in to your Lemonade account through the Lemonade app or on the Lemonade website (www.lemonade.com).
Navigate to your policy from the home screen, 'My Account' settings, or by selecting the policy you wish to cancel.
Select the option to 'Cancel Policy' or click the 'cancel' link within your policy details or under the Policy Status section.
Follow any on-screen prompts or chat with the chatbot assistant (Maya) to confirm your cancellation request.
You will receive an email confirmation once your policy is canceled.

Progressive

Contact Progressive customer service at 1-888-671-4405 to cancel your policy.
If you plan to continue driving, do not cancel your existing policy until you have secured a new one.
Ask your current insurer to cancel your existing policy effective the first day of your new policy to prevent any gaps in coverage.
Be aware that gaps in coverage, even for a short period, could lead to increased insurance rates.
Customer service is available 24/7 to assist with cancellations.

Cancellation Methods

Lemonade

App
Website
Email
Phone

Progressive

Phone call

Additional Notes

Lemonade

Cancellation can be done at any time.
Canceling your policy will eliminate any potential Giveback associated with your policy.
If you wish to return to Lemonade in the future, be aware that insurance prices change, so your new policy may come with a different rate.
Alternatively, you can cancel by drafting an email with your account information and policy number, and sending it to help@lemonade.com.
You can also cancel by calling Lemonade customer support at 1-844-733-8666 with your policy number ready.

Progressive

You can cancel your Progressive policy at any time.
If you pay your full premium upfront, you will typically receive a refund when you cancel.
If you pay your premium monthly, refund eligibility depends on the timing of your cancellation.
Avoiding gaps in coverage is essential to prevent potential issues and higher future rates.
You can manage your policy online to make changes, view details, and report claims.

Read the full cancellations

Lemonade Cancellation

Full details, exceptions, and more

Progressive Cancellation

Full details, exceptions, and more